Transparent log of burn events

In accordance with the need for graduated sanctions in any healthy commons[^1], The Commons Stack may destroy some of the non-monetary token, CSTK, which represents reputation in the Trusted Seed. We laid out these conditions:

On the off chance that the Commons Stack Association loses faith in a member of the Trusted Seed, (specifically, if we suspect that their motivation is to extract value from these systems rather than to nurture them,) then graduated sanctions may be applied to the member in question, the most severe of which would be the burning of that person’s CSTK tokens. If it becomes necessary for us to take punitive action against a CSTK holder, the sanction(s) will be carried out with maximum transparency and community consultation.

But in March, we found a different reason to burn CSTK: an accounting error caused a doubling of one person's tokens. This called into question how we can maintain integrity in these scenarios. The result is this burn log. While it's not necessary to initiate a community process over an accounting error, we will document it here for transparency. In the event of future token burns (those warranting more community engagement or not), they will also be logged here.

BURN EVENTS

Date	Reason for Burn	Etherscan Link
02 March 2020	Accounting error, 706 tokens were sent twice	https://etherscan.io/tx/0xd799e7750f067942e2227e0ac17df00eedf9cbbf9cae7fbc96157a5649122e83
31 March 2020	Member's address compromised, reissued here	https://etherscan.io/tx/0xff32aeb2ec312ce17e1b4b8029b30ef7fb8c428f519b7be26cc3660ef44eb3ec
15 June 2020	Contract wallet can't interact with CSTK tokens	https://etherscan.io/tx/0x07cf4ac6bba6a3b119d20bb396de06e5c64ccc6f19ae6a403ab964e2778df105
15 June 2020	Accounting error, 302 tokens were sent twice	https://etherscan.io/tx/0x62446feff99bbf28a5d75a4890166fdbe749876e81cfe9907082c0d87f1bfc5c
13 September 2020	Address Change Request, replacement tokens sent vote 17	https://aragon.1hive.org/?#/csdao/0xaa89fb730a83146cbf06661fd436e7445b4d0232/vote/16/
24 September 2020	Accounting error	https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0x542bb62f7e607ba046d14bf177260d465ca176fa914f2df907333ea68e630df2/token-transfers
12 October 2020	Address change request	https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0x6cfe7e4a1c8f9cbef257e390ab4f83caa119abc53d5547c8620eff69f5f476d0/token-transfers
12 October 2020	Member lost access to keys	https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0x2933fa4c9695e96ba8da65222c8c727127da157fc62a8653b5896ccfc078db0c/token-transfers
12 October 2020	Address change request	https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0xea7d956a88bcb45945c2065d8a6326f9da7604f09599b827171b47263d4bbe87/token-transfers
12 October 2020	Member's address compromised	https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0x271bc320d0def0ae10db296a69616171a6b48808c096faeef3ecd5680723d918/token-transfers
12 December 2020	20 Members requested to change their addresses	See our DAO votes #31-50
29 January 2021	CSTK minted for DApp development testing	See our DAO votes #66 & 67
11 February 2021	Accounting error	See our DAO votes #69 & 70
25 February 2021	Accounting error	https://aragon.1hive.org/?#/csdao/0xaa89fb730a83146cbf06661fd436e7445b4d0232/vote/82/
25 February 2021	3 Members terminated their membership	See our DAO votes #78-80
25 February 2021	8 Members requested to change their addresses	See our DAO votes #77, 81 and 83-88
11 March 2021	Address change request	https://aragon.1hive.org/?#/csdao/0xaa89fb730a83146cbf06661fd436e7445b4d0232/vote/93/
11 March 2021	After a live test of the DApp with a new address, CSTK requiered being moved to the correct member's address	https://aragon.1hive.org/?#/csdao/0xaa89fb730a83146cbf06661fd436e7445b4d0232/vote/94/
24 April 2021	4 Members requested to change their addresses	See our DAO votes #103-106
9 May 2021	3 Members requested to change their addresses	See our DAO votes #113-115
25 May 2021	1 member terminated their membership	https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0xbaecb568a6c0baed21a20d204868c924a009fac2e984526643ca47407c3f5ed4
27 May 2021	CSTK minted for DApp development testing	https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0xb717eb70813dd66eaeb26ecfcb81070e5acfb3f8648839abd1d824ae8fb3b79e
27 May 2021	Address change requests	See link A and B
27 May 2021	Errors prompted by bridge failure	See link A and B
27 May 2021	THE BURN: An unique event where CSTK from non activated members was burned	List of 155 burns
28 May 2021	CSTK minted for DApp development testing	See link A and B
01 June 2021	Griff's CSTK Ratio Adjustment Burn	https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0xd7699cf753beae1908e98520a3a4f2ca32ce532d7b5431baa792ac8056a8f3e7
09 June 2021	Accounting Error	https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0xb0487acb2995ee31f9ac2ef47884ef15f47d1bd23c67ed8f8b472f166982837a
10 June 2021	Address change request	https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0x2737ed9e680bd6758b0f10d8d6bdc0503c736154438b76d152f53b4ea85c73b1
16 June 2021	Membership termination	See link A and B
13 July 2021	Membership terminations	See link A, B, C, D, E, and F
30 July 2021	Accounting Error	https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0xb554c581015d3712742294affeb1883a1a0e623f246ecbef75532aad1f65ad7e
03 August 2021	Address change requests	See link A and B
10 August 2021	Address change request	https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0x19de4294abdad8645fa3c5fc0e44725485f7436bee44a3c5be28713b6a3c51d7
11 August 2021	Accounting Error	https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0x15b2e8fe5e5e49350fa8784db65cbc002cd2bbc08f9ab33b94361ed665f189d8
11 August 2021	Address change request	https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0x2b339532335108525de9670b8df63efa5fb0ac886989fd0686f698fbed0d9cf8
17 August 2021	Address change request	https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0x3ef53cfaff36470724b809953ed37718c207fd6352ab09d1b67b6377f6df5172
20 October 2021	Address change request	https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0x26a3b1c4077d8e679fc343f4efe7662c5aaffb3d1218239ae8f9894da9755b9d
15 November 2021	Accounting Error	https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0x5af922b57fac8ab51c661bdcf716962c5def43d8591d2e212053c075725eae2b
23 December 2021	Membership Termination	See link A and B
2 March 2022	Address change request	See link A and B

[^1]: http://www.makecommoningwork.fed.wiki/view/graduated-sanctions-according-to-ostrom